An Open letter to the Senate

James Hayhurst
2 min readFeb 12, 2021

Dear Senators,

As you consider whether or not to convict Donald J. Trump of high crimes and misdemeanors while president, I am aware the Republicans among you fear Trump’s voter base and political influence could cause you to lose the next election. With that in mind, I’ve prepared a draft letter you can use to defend your vote to convict:

Dear citizens of the great state of ___________,

I have voted to convict Donald J. Trump for high crimes and misdemeanors while serving as president. I know many of you voted for him and believe he represents your political aspirations, and so feel this is a betrayal of beliefs you hold dear. Let me assure you, I steadfastly share your conservative beliefs, and vow to continue to advance our shared values as your senator.

However, a greater issue is at stake here — the foundation of democracy, the sanctity our election process. Starting from grade school, we elect our fellows to office — class president, mayor, county supervisor, congressman, senator, president — and in every case, the peaceful acceptance of the outcome of the election is crucial for maintaining a civil, functioning society.

Imagine if Johnny claims Suzy “stole the vote” for class president, and then despite an investigation of voting irregularities by school officials (who find none), Johnny continues to insist the election was rigged, his victory stolen. He bullies the students who conducted the election, and incites his buddies to stage a violent break-in of the principal’s office to “stop the steal” . . . if Johnny is not expelled for his misbehavior, then all crimes become permissible and the school will quickly descend into chaos.

This situation is no different. If Donald Trump’s actions are not condemned, then what he did — inciting an insurrection to stop the lawful process of democratic election — becomes permissible for all. In a few short years, our society will devolve into chaos. Every national election will be contested by the loser, regardless of the absence of evidence that the election was unfair. The loser can threaten election officials and incite violence to seize power. We will devolve into mob rule and our glorious democratic experiment will come to an ignominious end.

Yes, I want to be your senator — but I love our constitution, our democracy and our Republic more than I love my job. When time comes to vote, vote for democracy, as I did today, when I voted to convict Donald J. Trump, a bully who continues to propagate the outrageous lie that his victory was stolen, who invited a mob to our capital for the purpose of an insurrection that nearly destroyed our democracy and the American way of life.

Sincerely, Senator ________

--

--